Comparison and Contrast between Spanish and French

Catholic Schooling is a significant issue in the early American history. After Christopher Columbus landed in 1492, the English people, French, and Spaniard extended their territories and assimilated Indian by assigning missionaries and governors to develop Catholic schools in the New World. The Catholic schools in European colonies were established not only for educating European¡¦s own Catholic descents but also for making Saint Mary and Jesus Chris known by Indians. Spanish priests had accomplished better missionary tasks than the other European colonial empires like France and England. Their Catholic preaches arrived the in southern parts of the Mississippi River before 1700, and the west and south area of the Mississippi after 1700.

I believe the reason why Spanish accomplished the missionary job more successfully than the others is that they paid enough reverence to Indian¡¦s tribe traditions and customs. Spanish missionaries understood that the tribe people have to retain their habits like complex cosmology worship, hunting game, and defending practice; therefore, they preserved Indian¡¦s traditional activities when converting them into Catholics. Spanish bishops transformed Indian¡¦s superstitions into Christianality step by step gently and gradually. At the same time, the Spanish missionaries traveled and fight together with tribe military soldiers from hostile attacks and introduced new industrialization technique to improve Indian¡¦s agriculture. This apparently revealed Spanish¡¦s determination to assimilate Indian and to transfer Spanish civilization to improve Indian¡¦s daily lives.

Compared with French, Spanish missionaries were more effective and lucky because they encountered stronger and bigger tribes like the Mayans, the Incas, the Aztec, and the Sioux. Bigger tribes were more stable and their people were willing to learn and assimilated. They arrived in these stronger tribe areas in the US from Mexico and West Indies and transmitted the grace and love of God to settled communities such as the Pueblo of New Mexico. On the contrary, the French missionaries came across weaker nomadic tribes like the Mi'kmaq the Algonquian in Maine, New York, Illinois and Louisiana from Canada and finally did not Christianized them aggressively and effectively.

In 1694, a French explorer, Antoine de la Mothe Cadillac took control of the area around Detroit, and urged that the northern tribes come to live in the settlement, mingle with the French settlers, learn the language, and intermarry. He wished to lead mixed force of White and Indians to defend the fort against the English, the Iroquois, and the Sioux; however, he did not achieve this goal. In fact, French priests were unfortunately accused by Jesuits that they gave the Indian brandy, turned the women into prostitutes, and did not founded enough Catholic schools in their regions.

Unlike the Spanish missionaries, the French did not interfere with the Indian¡¦s cultures. In other words, they did not try to enhance their life quality or transfer French modernization to them. French let the converted Native Americans lived outside the forts, followed their own ways of live, and allow them enter the palisade in times of danger. Actually, French people did better in educating their own settlers. For example, the Ursuline Sisters from France introduced models of Catholic schooling of women by establishing a French young woman Catholic School.

Many events illustrated that French missionaries did not use reasonable ways to Christianize Indian. For example, a French explorer, Jacques Cartier returned to France to tell Francis I about the New World. He brought back two original Americans to show that these people deserved the opportunity to be converted to Catholics. The ridiculous thing was that only two Indian people brought to France made Francis I enthusiastically accepted the idea of converting a whole tribe to Christianity without a perfect plan. Their failure derived from the mistake of stereotyping. From the perspectives of positivism, two Indians do not reflect the true intention and inclination of a whole tribe population. Even though these two Indians expressed that they really have strong motivation to believe Catholicism, Francis I should not easily made religion joined his economic and political motives to explore his new lands in America. Without a complete and careful preparation and arrangement, French missionaries merely imitated and traced the Spanish steps of avoiding the Indians contaminated from traders, and defending the fort against English and the other tribes. France missionaries did not develop enough Catholic schools for Indians because they neither gained enough trust from Indians and nor transmit their France civilization, industrialization, and modernization to them. They made the ¡§converted¡¨ Native Americans follow their own original ways of living. French people failed because under their control, the Indian people¡¦s life styles were not updated or improved by supports from France.

I believe that both Spanish and French missionaries aimed to make the Catholic schooling as a part of what¡¦s called Americanism by Pope Leo XIII on their land. Besides trying to improve the material lives of the Native Americans, Spanish missionaries centered their concerns on the spiritual gifts they sought to share with the Indians and established sufficient Catholic schools for both Spanish and Indians. However, the French people tend to built Catholic schools in tribe areas to meet the needs of their own settlers. For example, a young female Catholic School was built by Ursuline Sisters in New Orleans in 1718.

Indeed, converting Indian or immigrants to accept Christianity and be baptized as a Catholic is not a painless task. As I see it, the Spanish governors and missionaries had devoted to their missionary works by offering abundant budgets and powerful militaries. Nowadays in the US, I think that for achieving a goal of Christianizing new immigrants and inviting them go to Catholic schools, the missionaries, administrators and teachers in Catholic school should refer to Spanish¡¦s model, in which Catholic schools established as cultural melting pots and improved better learning environments.




Please do not pass this sample essay as your own, otherwise you will be accused of plagiarism. Our writers can write any custom essay for you!
  • Outstanding Historical Events of Canada
  • Modern Canada originated as a country of immigrants. Before the 15th century Canada was populated by different Indian tribes. In the far north there were tribes of Eskimos. An English seaman, John Cabot, discovered the island of Newfoundland in 1497. Then many settlements of Spanish, English and French fishermen appeared on the coasts of Newfoundland.
  • Great Plains
  • Written by: Rapidfries What were the economic, political, technological and social changes that took place on the Great Plains between 1800 and 1900? Many things happened on the Great Plains in a century, The political changes were something new to the Indians, they were used to having their own tribe to themselves, and other tribes ruled other
  • The Neglect Of The Native American Indian
  • Sample essay topic, essay writing: The Neglect Of The Native American Indian - 793 words Nearly every Native American Indian tribe has experienced some kind of neglect or discrimination. The white man has forcefully moved tribes from their homes, broken treaties that were promised to them, and senselessly slaughtered thousands of innocent Indian men, women, and
  • The Apaches
  • Sample essay topic, essay writing: The Apaches - 1083 words Due to the educating of the Apaches and their persistence behavior, they flourished in the Great Plains region of the US. The American Indian Tribe first got their name 'Apache' from the Yuma Indians. The word Apache means 'fighting men'. They were hunters, farmers and seed
  • The Long Death of the Plains Indians
  • Written by: Kathsscrn "The long death” is an appropriate title for the book describing the slow death of the Plains Indian’s way of life. It took many years for the white man to alter and ruin the lives and homeland of the Plains Indians as the tribes suffered tremendously in the process. The Indians soon became